The Supreme Court has ruled that universities and colleges may apply Regulation 10 of the UGC Regulations, 2018, when awarding marks for teaching experience during shortlisting for Assistant Professor interviews. The decision arose from recruitment disputes involving the University of Allahabad and its affiliated colleges. It sets aside the Allahabad High Court’s judgment that had restricted Regulation 10’s application to appointments and promotions requiring prior service.
The ruling concerns the assessment of experience as a shortlisting factor, not the minimum educational qualifications for appointment. A candidate may meet the required qualifications for Assistant Professor and still not receive experience marks, or be called for an interview, if the claimed service does not satisfy the applicable regulatory conditions and the candidate’s overall score falls below the shortlisting cutoff.
What the dispute concerned
The University of Allahabad advertised Assistant Professor posts in September 2021. Iswar Saran Degree College and Allahabad Degree College issued related advertisements in 2022. Geetanjali Tiwari (Pandey), who applied for Assistant Professor posts in Sanskrit, had the required educational qualifications but was not shortlisted because her academic score did not reach the cutoff.
The shortlisting system under the UGC Regulations uses academic scores, with two marks available for each year of teaching or postdoctoral experience under clause 7 of Tables 3A and 3B. The University and colleges did not count the candidate’s claimed periods of guest-faculty and contractual teaching because, they said, those periods did not meet Regulation 10’s conditions.
The candidate had claimed contractual teaching service from October 2004 to March 2010, for which she received a monthly honorarium of Rs. 5,000, and guest-faculty experience between 2016 and 2021. Regulation 10(e) excludes previous service as a guest lecturer from qualifying teaching experience. Under Regulation 10(f)(iii), contractual teaching service counts only when the gross emoluments meet the prescribed comparison with the monthly gross salary of a regularly appointed teacher at the relevant level.
Why the Supreme Court overturned the High Court ruling
The Allahabad High Court had held that Regulation 10 did not govern experience marks for Assistant Professor shortlisting because previous teaching experience was not a minimum eligibility requirement for that post. It directed that experience be assessed without applying the regulation’s remuneration-related conditions, while protecting appointments already made.
The Supreme Court disagreed. It said that Regulation 10 expressly refers to Assistant Professors, and the High Court’s interpretation effectively removed those words from the regulations. The Court explained that reading down a provision is a limited legal method, generally used to preserve a rule’s validity. It cannot be used simply because a court considers another arrangement preferable or believes an otherwise valid rule produces a harsh outcome. Courts should interpret rules, not rewrite them.
The Court also distinguished eligibility from shortlisting. Eligibility sets the minimum qualifications a candidate must possess to apply. Shortlisting is a screening process used to decide which eligible applicants will be called for interview, particularly where applications substantially exceed available vacancies. A reasonable and relevant screening criterion can be used without changing the minimum eligibility requirements.
In support of this distinction, the Court relied on recruitment principles recognised in earlier decisions, including M.P. Public Service Commission v. Navnit Kumar Potdar. It held that the academic-score method in Tables 3A and 3B, read with Regulations 4 and 10, was consistent with the UGC framework.
NAAC A+
Central UniversityAllahabad UniversityPrayagraj, Uttar PradeshAdmission: CUET UG, CUET PG, NET/JRFEst. 1887View details
NIRF #6 (2025)Banaras Hindu UniversityVaranasi, Uttar PradeshAdmission: CUET UG, CUET PG, NET/JRFEst. 1916 · 1300 acresView details
NAAC A+
NIRF #10 (2025)Aligarh Muslim UniversityAligarh, Uttar PradeshAdmission: CUET UG, NET/JRF, NEET UGEst. 1920View details
NAAC A++
NIRF #37 (2025)Babasaheb Bhimrao Ambedkar UniversityLucknow, Uttar PradeshAdmission: CUET UG, CUET PG, NET/JRFEst. 1996View details
Central UniversityRajiv Gandhi National Aviation UniversityRaebareli, Uttar PradeshAdmission: Own Entrance, JEE Main, CATEst. 2013View details
Central UniversityRani Lakshmi Bai Central Agricultural UniversityJhansi, Uttar PradeshAdmission: CUET UG, ICAR AIEEA, NET/JRFEst. 2014View detailsWhat the ruling means for applicants
The judgment does not say that all contractual teaching experience is excluded. It confirms that such experience may count when it satisfies Regulation 10’s conditions. In the candidate’s case, the earlier contractual remuneration did not meet the relevant requirement, and guest-faculty service was excluded under the regulation. The Court also noted that the University had awarded experience marks to other contractual teachers whose remuneration was equivalent to the prescribed regular faculty salary.
For applicants, the practical point is that experience marks depend on the type of service and the regulatory conditions applying to it. A period described as teaching work does not automatically qualify for marks under the shortlisting table. Applicants should distinguish between evidence that they possess minimum eligibility qualifications and evidence that a particular period of employment qualifies for experience marks.
The decision also addresses the legal challenge to the remuneration condition. The Supreme Court allowed the civil appeals, set aside the High Court’s common judgment and dismissed the connected proceedings. It upheld the institutions’ ability to apply Regulation 10 while awarding shortlisting marks under clause 7 of Tables 3A and 3B. The ruling does not itself announce a new Allahabad University recruitment cycle or change a current application deadline. Applicants should read the applicable recruitment notice and regulations for the criteria governing a particular selection.



